Sensex in a V-style recovery: Are we back to good old boom time?
Since 2005, I had written about booming Indian stock market three times on the occasion of Vinayaka Chavithi. In 2005, 2006 and 2007, the market was at or close to a new high for the year and showed upward trend. The Sensex hit its lifetime high of 21,206.77 (intraday) on Jan 11, 2008. At that time of euphoria, analysts were predicting Sensex to hit 25,000. But the US and Euopean markets were showing clear downward trend, and Indian market could not withstand the world wide market decline. On the eve of Vinayaka Chaviti (on September 3, 2008), the Sensex closed around 15,000. It was time to write my report, but I did not have any clue where the market was heading!
So I decided skip my report for 2008 Vinayaka Chavithi. I did not want to write something, which would end up being a bad prediction and confuse the readers.
Through the past year, I re-read my past articles and closely examined my assumptions, predictions and recommendations to see if those were holding up during this “Great Recession” in the US and some world economies. I had stated clearly that stock markets are not predictable and carry higher risk than other investments. To reduce this risk, I recommended systematic investment in well-diversified funds for the long term. The current word wide recession and declining stock markets has put to test the benefits of (a) diversification and (b) long term investment. Let us examine if these two basic tenets of investment helped or failed the common investors.
Before the market recovery started a few months ago, investors found diversification to offer no protection from the ups and mostly down of the markets. In this ”Great Recession”, every sector (Finance, Technology, Energy, Real-estate, Utilities etc.) and every index (Sensex, Dow, S&P500, Nasdaq etc.) in every region (US, Europe, India, China, Brazil, developed or emerging markets) showed the same declining trends (except for Gold). We did not see much of orthogonal behavior of different sectors and markets as advertised: an upward sector to cushion losses from a downward sector. However, this recession is a special case, and diversification offered no protection. We have to wait and see if diversification is beneficial during the recovery phase. The current trends indicate a benefit - some sectors and regions are recovering faster than others. In any case, it is better not put all eggs in one basket.
The benefits of long-term investment also came into question during this recession. The people near retirement with most of their savings in stocks and bonds faced a rude shock with sharp (30% or more) decline in their net worth during this recession. If these retires are in their late 60’s or older, they may never see the levels of their wealth at the time of market peak in 2007. For those people, idea of investing for the long term is meaningless. For younger workers in 30s and 40s, there is a high probability of recovery of the losses in next 5-10 years. If you need money in a 1-5 years, it is generally a bad idea to invest in stocks.
The Sensex on Vinayaka Chavithi in 2008 was around 15,000 and it closed at 15240.83 (on Friday) for Vinayaka Chavithi in 2009 after hitting a bottom around 8,160 in March this year. This looks like a classic V shaped recovery! Are we out of woods? Is the market going back to its boom time in late 90’s and early 00’s? Nobody can give you the answer. But staying in the market and continuing systemic investment during highs and lows will be beneficial to you financial health in the long run.
Happy Vinyaka Chavithi.
Govinda Rao Bhisetti
August 23, 2009
PS: Thanks to my son, Harsha for proof-reading the article and for helpful suggestions.
Please add your comments to my blog at http://seedindia.blogspot.com/
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home